· 3 items
City Council, Monday, November 16
What happened, from the recording. The hosts take it up in San Diego's next episode.
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
City Council Monday, November 16
3 items
The recording · Monday Agenda City Council · Monday Agenda City Council
Closed session: one potential lawsuit and two labor negotiations
Lawsuits and settlementsPublic employees
In the morning the council took public comment on three closed-session items, then met privately. CS-1 was a conference with legal counsel on starting litigation (one case). CS-2 and CS-3 were conferences with the city's labor negotiators. The City Attorney's office changed who would attend. At the end of the day it reported that the council had voted in closed session to start litigation on CS-1. The defendants and other details will be released on request once the case is filed. 00:12:34
- Closed-session vote on CS-1 to start litigation, reported out by the City Attorney's office; Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 05:57:48
- The City Attorney corrected the list of closed-session participants, saying the new Human Resources director would attend for CS-2 and CS-3 in place of the person listed, and that Commission on Police Practices staff would attend for CS-2 00:13:09
Councilmember asks for SDPD transparency at immigration arrests
ImmigrantsPolicing
During non-agenda comments from officials, Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9) described a federal immigration arrest in District 9 the previous Friday. He asked the Mayor's office for two things: that SDPD publish a public report whenever officers respond to a scene where federal immigration agents are present, and that officers help families find a relative who has been detained. The Mayor's office committed to both. He also reported that an eight-year-old boy he had spoken about the week before, who was taken during an immigration check-in, is back with his family. 00:48:09
▶ Hear it Will police publicly report their presence at immigration arrests? · 0:38
- A councilmember reported that the eight-year-old boy he had raised the week before, taken during an immigration check-in, had been returned to his family 00:48:09
- A councilmember described an arrest in his district where, he said, an ICE agent shoved an 18-year-old to the ground and threatened her while her father was detained, and said the family and neighbors did not feel protected by the SDPD officers who arrived 00:49:13
- A councilmember asked the Mayor's office to have SDPD publish a public report within three business days each time officers respond where federal immigration agents are present, saying why officers were there, what they did, which agencies were present, and whether a judicial warrant was shown 00:50:14
- A councilmember asked that officers at a federal immigration arrest record which agency made the arrest, give the family that information in writing, and help families find where a relative was taken 00:51:16
- The mayor's office committed the Mayor's office to both requests, including updating the resource links on the city website and making sure officers who deal with witnesses have the information 00:52:33
Council ends police use of license plate readers and smart streetlights, keeps 52 other surveillance policies Item 200
Surveillance technologyPolicing
This was the annual review under the city's TRUST surveillance ordinance. Each year the council approves, modifies or rescinds the police department's use policies for its surveillance technologies. SDPD presented its 2025 report covering 54 technologies and proposed two sets of changes. For automated license plate readers (ALPR), the vendor Flock, it proposed tighter limits and access controls and a rule to notify the council of data breaches. For drones, it proposed folding 16 policies into one. Subitem A (R-2027-162) would keep 53 policies in effect with their changes, the merged drone policy among them, and Subitem B (R-2027-163) would keep the ALPR policy in effect with its new limits (agenda). The license plate readers and smart streetlights run under a single contract with Ubiquia, with 500 ALPR cameras installed citywide and an annual payment of about $2 million due in the second half of December. The City Attorney's office said rescinding a use policy means the city must stop using that technology. The council split the smart streetlight policy out of Subitem A and voted separately to rescind both the ALPR and the smart streetlight policies. It kept the other 52 policies in effect, including the merged drone policy. The three motions on the policies themselves asked the city's labor relations team to decide whether the city's recognized employee organizations must get notice and a chance to bargain. 00:54:09
- Henry Foster (Councilmember, District 4) moved to rescind the automated license plate recognition (ALPR) surveillance use policy (Subitem B), and asked the city's labor relations team to decide whether the rescission requires notice and bargaining with employee organizations under the Meyers-Milias-Brown Act and to return to council if there are bargainable impacts; seconded by Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9); Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) and Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 7-0. 04:40:44
- Henry Foster (Councilmember, District 4) moved to split Subitem A so the smart streetlights use policy could be voted on separately as Subitem C; seconded by Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9); Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) and Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 6-1. No: Vivian Moreno (Councilmember, District 8). 04:42:45
- Henry Foster (Councilmember, District 4) moved to approve the staff recommendation for the rest of Subitem A, keeping 52 department surveillance use policies in effect under the TRUST ordinance with the identified changes, and asked labor relations to review whether the change to the unmanned aircraft systems (drone) policy requires notice and bargaining with employee organizations; seconded by Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9); Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) and Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 7-0. 04:45:05Ayes: Joe LaCava, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Vivian Moreno, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Jennifer Campbell, Marni von Wilpert. Moved by Henry Foster, seconded by Sean Elo-Rivera. From the clerk's record
- Henry Foster (Councilmember, District 4) moved to rescind the smart streetlights surveillance use policy (Subitem C), with the same request for labor relations review; seconded by Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9); Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) and Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 5-2. No: Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7), Vivian Moreno (Councilmember, District 8). 05:17:41Ayes: Joe LaCava, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Kent Lee, Sean Elo-Rivera. Noes: Raul Campillo, Vivian Moreno. Absent: Jennifer Campbell, Marni von Wilpert. Moved by Henry Foster, seconded by Sean Elo-Rivera. From the clerk's record
- SDPD staff presented SDPD's 2025 annual surveillance report and asked for approval to keep using 54 surveillance technologies, none of them new 00:54:53
- SDPD staff said the drone change merges 16 largely duplicative policies into one without adding capabilities 00:55:53
- SDPD staff said the drones covered are already approved and are separate from the Drone as First Responder program, which is still going through the TRUST process 00:55:53
- SDPD staff described new auditing rules adopted in 2025, under which a subject-matter expert for each technology tracks 10 data points and audits quarterly 00:56:58
- SDPD staff said 500 ALPR cameras are installed across the city and their locations are posted online 00:59:29
- SDPD staff credited ALPR with helping in more than 700 arrests and the recovery of 689 stolen vehicles, and cited three straight years of 20% year-over-year declines in auto theft 01:00:31
- SDPD staff said searches for immigration enforcement and reproductive health are prohibited, supervisors audit searches weekly, and data is deleted after 30 days unless kept as evidence 01:02:39
- SDPD staff said SDPD has never used data from its ALPR system for immigration enforcement 01:03:39
- A councilmember cited a June 2025 configuration error that let other California law enforcement agencies search San Diego's license plate data, which he said led to more than 12,000 unauthorized searches 03:44:43
- A councilmember raised a conflict-of-interest concern: a former SDPD captain who oversaw the surveillance program and the sole-source selection of Flock later went to work for Flock 03:45:46
- A councilmember said erroneous Flock identifications have been tied to two wrongful arrests and a shooting, all now in litigation 03:46:48
- A councilmember recalled pushing earlier in the year to cut this fiscal year's funding for smart streetlights and Flock 03:47:49
- SDPD staff answered that the ALPR camera and the smart streetlight camera are separate units and the ALPR camera can be removed by itself 03:48:53
- The police chief's office explained that ending both technologies would allow the whole contract to be scrapped, while ending only ALPR would require negotiating a contract change with the vendor 03:49:17
- A councilmember argued that, given how the earlier GE streetlight cameras stayed in place after cancellation, the only way to make sure the technology isn't used is to remove the cameras, and asked who has authority to order removal 03:51:05
- An attorney for the city advised that the council's action is to approve, modify or rescind the use policy, that rescinding means use must stop, and that removing the cameras would likely require coordination with the vendor and purchasing 03:51:38
- The mayor's office said the administration would follow the council's direction: shut off the system, ask the vendors to remove the cameras (which it believes the contract requires at no cost to the city), and give the council a work plan for dismantling the 500 cameras by the end of the week 03:52:26
- The police chief's office said the vendors had pledged to deactivate the ALPR system and delete its data within 24 hours of a council vote and send formal notice, which would be shared with the council 03:53:04
- A councilmember argued that opponents of ALPR want safety as much as anyone and that the debate was over how to achieve it, which he said depends on trust 03:56:13
- A councilmember blamed the situation on the city's refusal to follow the advice of its own Privacy Advisory Board 03:57:13
- A councilmember asked whether SDPD's earlier search of a domestic violence survivor's license plate had been disclosed to the council or the Privacy Advisory Board in the annual report; the answer from staff was no 03:58:14
- The police chief said the woman's plate was run to help corroborate a serious misconduct allegation against an SDPD employee by placing her and the officer in the same location, not because she was a domestic violence survivor 03:58:40
- The police chief said department procedure lists expressly prohibited uses, such as personal use, indiscriminate viewing, discrimination and harassment 03:59:59
- The police chief confirmed that in the case of the 19-year-old passenger who was shot, officers relied on the stolen-vehicle listing in a state and federal database without checking the basis for it, and noted the case is in litigation 04:03:28
- A councilmember argued that ALPR hits create false confidence that effectively presumes guilt, and called for removing license plate readers, not pausing them; he then seconded the motion 04:04:57
- A councilmember said his district has the highest density of Flock cameras and that he had announced a month earlier that he now wants them taken down 04:06:51
- A councilmember said ALPR has helped solve hate crimes and other crimes and his view of its effectiveness hasn't changed, but the political context under the Trump administration has 04:07:53
- A councilmember said he is confident the city's cameras are not used for immigration enforcement, but that fear of them is widespread in immigrant communities and the city should not add to it 04:08:53
- A councilmember proposed using the money saved by turning off the cameras to speed up police response times 04:12:39
- The council president pro tem recalled that after the 2025 approval he and the council president sent a memo asking SDPD to seek new vendors through competitive bidding 04:14:41
- The council president pro tem said little progress had been made on finding a new vendor in the year since 04:15:44
- The council president pro tem cited reports from parents that week of more ICE presence near local schools 04:16:46
- The council president pro tem said it was time to prioritize civil rights and limited public dollars, and supported rescinding the ALPR policy 04:16:46
- A councilmember said a configuration error put the city's cameras in 12,914 outside searches over nearly three weeks and that the incident was left out of the 2024 annual report at first 04:19:17
- A councilmember noted that the 2025 report lists four suspected policy violations, one of them sharing with an Arizona police agency after the sharing ban, and asked what the findings were 04:19:17
- SDPD staff said the Arizona sharing came just after the ban took effect, the officer's access was cut off and he was retrained, and the other three cases were metadata errors investigated by Internal Affairs 04:21:03
- A councilmember called it extremely concerning that an individual officer could share ALPR data, saying only the highest-ranking official should be able to approve sharing 04:21:49
- A councilmember said she has voted against ALPR since 2023 and would support the motion 04:23:53
- A councilmember said he had backed ALPR because it helped solve violent crimes in his district, including a murder in a Linda Vista park 04:24:33
- A councilmember said he had promised to reconsider if shown evidence of misuse in San Diego, and that tracking a domestic violence victim under a broad administrative exception leaves no real protection 04:25:43
- A councilmember noted that the police officers' union raised the use as a possible labor violation and the Mayor's team agreed to stop it 04:26:51
- A councilmember asked the police chief whether, in defending the program publicly, the department had mentioned that people connected to administrative cases could be tracked; the answer was not specifically 04:28:54
- A councilmember pushed back on public comments condemning police in general, saying most San Diegans approve of their officers 04:31:27
- A councilmember said the new evidence changed his position and he would support rescinding the ALPR policy 04:32:46
- The council president acknowledged voting at least three times in support of ALPR 04:33:41
- The council president recalled that in 2023 his office secured the council's authority to approve, modify or rescind use policies under the TRUST ordinance 04:35:45
- The council president said that a year after the council asked for a different vendor, none had been found and no request for information had been issued 04:35:45
- The council president said the savings, about $750,000 a year for ALPR or $2 million for the whole contract, would not help the FY 2027 budget but could matter for FY 2028; IBA staff later said the $2 million would be saved in FY 2027 if the December payment is not made 04:37:50
- The council president called for rescinding both the ALPR and the smart streetlight policies to start fresh 04:38:50
- A councilmember said she has always supported the smart streetlights separately from ALPR and would oppose splitting them out 04:42:15
- The mayor's office told the council no city policy prescribes or prohibits how departments build public support for the items they bring forward 04:48:16
- A councilmember objected to departments running public campaigns to win policy outcomes, saying it scares the public and makes the city look disorganized, and asked whether a campaign against the council's decision should be expected 04:48:50
- The city's chief operating officer said the council can expect operations staff, including police, to communicate from a factual basis 04:51:11
- A councilmember criticized the police department for using its communications resources in recent weeks to argue policy with the council, and cited a towing decision the department dismissed 04:51:38
- The council president pro tem asked whether rescinding the policies would save money this year, noting the ALPR portion was said to be about $750,000 and the full contract $2 million 04:53:36
- The Independent Budget Analyst explained that the FY 2027 budget includes the $2 million payment due in mid-to-late December, so not making it would be a current-year saving 04:55:48
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office confirmed that skipping the upcoming payment would save the general fund $2 million in fiscal year 2027 04:56:09
- The council president pro tem noted that the council cannot make mid-year budget adjustments, so how any savings are spent would be up to the administration; he supported rescinding the smart streetlights 04:56:29
- SDPD staff answered that smart streetlight cameras record ordinary video saved to a database and do not use AI processing 04:57:47
- A councilmember argued that the smart streetlight footage has evidentiary value, including footage defense attorneys can obtain to show innocence, and that its use policy is narrower than ALPR's; he would oppose rescinding it 04:58:51
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office said the contract bundles streetlights with ALPR, but the vendor recently indicated about $750,000 in savings if only ALPR is dropped, and $2 million a year if both are 05:00:26
- The council president cautioned against promising how any savings would be spent, noting the city drew on reserves to balance the budget, and called the vote a value judgment 05:02:52
- The council president argued that streetlight video is still surveillance because it can identify people and their behavior 05:03:54
- A councilmember cited a 2019 murder at a restaurant in Otay Mesa-Nestor that she said was solved with streetlight footage, and said she would vote no 05:05:04
- A councilmember questioned claims that crimes could not be solved without city cameras, pointing to private security cameras 05:06:15
- The police chief said he is open to council-acceptable limits on when and where smart streetlight cameras can be used 05:08:42
- The police chief confirmed that under the current policy and procedure, streetlight video could be used the same way as the ALPR images if it is for an official investigation 05:10:49
- A councilmember argued that rescinding the streetlight policy would allow a pause for the department to improve it and for the Privacy Advisory Board to weigh in 05:11:15
- A councilmember said he would not keep the streetlights on until the Privacy Advisory Board is confident privacy is protected under current policies 05:13:45
- The police chief said the department procedure went through meet-and-confer with the police union under the prior chief and was signed off in November 2023, and that it allows use in internal affairs investigations 05:16:28
Public comment
- Closed session (morning): seven commenters, two in person and five remote. Themes: whether the general fund has a structural deficit and the cost of labor; a suggestion to trim city pay rather than cut health and retirement benefits; criticism of closed-door negotiations; a call to equip firefighters better. One remote caller went off topic about undocumented workers filling potholes. The chair asked one in-person speaker to moderate their tone.
- Item 200 (surveillance technologies): an organized presentation by a coalition of advocacy groups, about 13 participants, asked the council to reject the ALPR use policy, direct the Mayor to remove the cameras, and visibly cover them until they are removed. They cited other cities where cameras kept running after councils voted against them or ordered them shut off, and the Privacy Advisory Board recommending against ALPR several times.
- Item 200: roughly 90 more people spoke in person and about 30 by phone or video. The great majority opposed ALPR and Flock and asked the council to cancel the Flock and Ubiquia contracts and take the cameras down, not just pause them. Cases cited repeatedly: a man jailed for nearly a month after a misread, a 19-year-old passenger shot after a stolen-car alert, SDPD tracking a domestic violence survivor during an internal investigation, and earlier data sharing with federal and out-of-state agencies. Other themes: Fourth Amendment privacy, fear in immigrant, Muslim and unhoused communities, AI error and bias, and moving the roughly $2 million a year to libraries, parks and youth programs. Many speakers were UCSD and USD students; several wore costumes or sang.
- Item 200: about seven speakers supported keeping ALPR. They said it helps solve crimes and find missing people, citing a murder solved with plate data, burglary, a 20% drop in auto theft, and abduction rescues, and urged better oversight instead of elimination. One caller asked whether the Privacy Advisory Board had approved all 54 technologies.
- Item 200 written input, as the clerk reported: 14 more speaker slips in opposition from people who chose not to speak, plus 10 eComments in favor and 106 opposed.
- Non-agenda public comment: 18 speakers, two in person and 16 remote. Three urged support for Centro Cultural de la Raza, which they said faces hate campaigns. Three raised lung cancer awareness, the Great American Smokeout and cigarette litter, and urged smoke-free and vape-free policies and limits on marijuana and tobacco advertising. Others raised safe sleeping and parking sites for homeless residents, flood and infrastructure risks at the Midway Rising project, shorter speaking times and the clerk's rules for submitting media, DUI prevention on the World Day of Remembrance for road traffic victims, and general criticism of the council. One caller made anti-Muslim remarks; one congratulated an election winner. The chair said one caller strayed into the surveillance item, which is not allowed in non-agenda comment.
What's next
- The Mayor's office said it would give the council a work plan for dismantling the 500 ALPR cameras citywide by the end of the week, and would ask the vendors to remove them, which it believes the contract requires at no cost to the city.
- Police staff said the vendors pledged to deactivate the ALPR system and delete its data within 24 hours of the vote and to send formal notice, which would be shared with the council.
- The council asked the city's labor relations team to decide whether the ALPR and smart streetlight rescissions and the drone policy change require notice and bargaining with employee organizations under the Meyers-Milias-Brown Act, and to return to council if there are bargainable impacts.
- The roughly $2 million annual contract payment is due in the second half of December. IBA staff said not paying it would save the general fund $2 million in FY 2027. Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council) noted that the council can't adjust the budget mid-year, so how any savings are spent is up to the administration.
- SDPD said it will return in February with its annual surveillance report on 2026 use. The Drone as First Responder program is still going through the TRUST process.
- The Mayor's office committed to Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9)'s requests: a public report within three business days whenever SDPD responds where federal immigration agents are present, and written information for families on which agency made an arrest and how to locate a detained relative.
- CS-1: details of the litigation the council voted to start will be disclosed on request once it is filed.
- Public notice: the final map 'Resubdivision of San Diego Tech Center' (9605 Scranton Road, Mira Mesa) can be appealed to the City Council within 10 calendar days of this meeting, the appeal filed with the City Clerk by 2:00 PM (agenda).
- The council next meets Tuesday, November 17, 2026, at 10 a.m.
Write to the City Council before its next meeting: its comment form