· 5 items
City Council, Monday, November 9
On the episode: Council approves Midway Rising; rewrites police commission reply
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
City Council Monday, November 9
5 items
Closed session: three pending lawsuits against the city
Lawsuits and settlements
Before recessing into closed session, the council took public comment on three existing-litigation cases (CS-1, CS-2 and CS-3) brought against the City of San Diego. Public commenters described the first two as sidewalk trip-and-fall cases and the third as a fatal police shooting. At the end of the night the City Attorney's office said there was nothing to report out. 00:11:27
- Report out from closed session. Result: no action. 08:11:58
Councilmember reports child detained by immigration agents
Immigrants
During the period for non-agenda communications from officials, a councilmember told the council about an eight-year-old San Diego Unified student who had been detained, and said immigrant communities in the city are living under threat. 00:38:39
- A councilmember reported getting a call Thursday from the San Diego Unified superintendent about an eight-year-old boy who missed school because he had been detained 00:38:41
- A councilmember said many people in the city live under constant threat from ICE, DHS and what the councilmember called the federal administration's abuse of power, with the Haitian community especially affected 00:39:42
Midway Rising: lease deal for the Sports Arena site and its environmental review Item 602
Development projectsAffordable housingHousing supply
The core real-estate deal for redeveloping the city-owned Sports Arena site at 3500, 3250, 3220 and 3240 Sports Arena Boulevard in District 2. Subitem A certifies the project's Subsequent Environmental Impact Report (No. 1106734/SCH No. 2023120451), with findings, a statement of overriding considerations and a mitigation monitoring program. Subitem B approves a Disposition and Development Agreement (DDA) ground-leasing the land to Midway Rising LLC, makes related findings, and waives Council Policy 700-10 (agenda). Staff described a roughly $4.2 billion project: up to 4,254 homes, 2,000 of them affordable at an average of no more than 60% of area median income, a 16,000-seat arena replacing the current one, 130,000 square feet of retail, and about 14.5 acres of parks and public space. The city keeps ownership; vertical ground leases run 85 years. City revenue comes from ground and participation rent on market-rate housing and retail and a per-ticket arena fee that starts in year 11; no rent is charged on the affordable housing sites. The review found some impacts that can't be fully mitigated. 00:43:25
▶ Hear it A member asks the developer for $2 million for traffic · 1:02
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved the staff recommendation (certify the SEIR and approve the DDA) with amendments offered by Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council), shown on screen and in a handout, giving the city a share of net refinancing proceeds; Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council) seconded and Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) accepted the amendments; Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) was absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 07:18:17Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Vivian Moreno, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Marni von Wilpert. Moved by Jennifer Campbell, seconded by Kent Lee. From the clerk's record
- The Economic Development Department said the developer must build 2,000 affordable units on site averaging no more than 60% of area median income 00:46:48
- The Economic Development Department said the $4.2 billion project does not pencil out without an enhanced infrastructure financing district, with the developer taking on the upfront risk 00:48:48
- The Economic Development Department said that since committee, staff added language barring the site from becoming an affordable-housing receiver site until all other financing options are exhausted 00:53:59
- The Economic Development Department explained that once the developer's initial equity is repaid, the city gets 0.5% of modified gross revenue from market-rate housing and retail through year 55, rising to 2.5% after 00:58:13
- The Economic Development Department said arena ticket-fee rent is waived for the first ten years and starts in year eleven, escalating 3% a year 00:58:13
- The Economic Development Department said the city will not charge rent for the affordable housing pad sites or share in their sale proceeds 01:00:18
- The Economic Development Department projected total ground rent over the life of the leases at almost $900 million in nominal dollars, not counting sale proceeds or the ticket fees held behind the return hurdle 01:04:34
- City staff said that even with mitigation, impacts on land use, transportation, historical and tribal cultural resources and noise remain significant and unavoidable 01:28:44
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office estimated city revenues over the century-long agreements at $884 million to $1.2 billion, worth about $38 million to $69 million in present value at a 4.5% discount rate 01:31:58
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office concluded that the agreement is a reasonable balance of risk, financial return and public benefit for the city 01:33:04
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office cautioned that 75% of arena ticket fees accrue behind a 16.5% levered return hurdle, and the city would not collect them if the developer or later owners never reach it 01:37:30
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office said an IBA report estimated roughly 200 to 800 affordable units elsewhere in the city that could be eligible to shift to Midway Rising, but only with city approval 01:40:39
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office flagged falling tax-credit pricing and stiffer competition for state affordable-housing grants as a risk to financing every affordable phase 01:41:39
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office noted the city would commit nearly 50 acres of public land for roughly a century, limiting future alternative uses of the site 01:43:39
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office said the developer had agreed to DDA changes letting the city share in future net refinancing proceeds, which would need to be added in the council's final action 01:44:41
- A councilmember asked staff what is being done about access into the neighborhood from the rest of the city, citing constituents' worries about getting in and out of Point Loma 05:58:24
- City staff said the project will build a roundabout at Hancock and Kurtz and widen Hancock Street from two lanes to four 06:00:16
- A councilmember asked the developer whether claims made in public comment were true, including that the first homes would take ten years 06:02:21
- A Midway Rising representative said this was untrue and that affordable and market-rate housing are phased to be delivered together 06:03:23
- A councilmember said the updated DDA generally bars using the project's affordable units to satisfy other developments' obligations, with a narrow exception requiring city approval at its sole discretion and state housing department confirmation 06:10:40
- A councilmember offered amendments giving the city 5% of net refinancing proceeds above a 19% return, rising to 10% on later refinancings above a higher threshold 06:11:44
- A councilmember acknowledged the financing, construction and market risks but said supporting the package means weighing them against the benefits 06:14:47
- A councilmember agreed with the IBA that the deal is a reasonable and fair transaction given the city's goals, citing housing affordability 06:15:28
- A councilmember asked development staff why the transit improvements are scheduled for phase two rather than phase one, as the Planning Commission and many speakers urged 06:17:37
- City staff said phase one includes existing bus routes, partial transit lanes, free private shuttles and a multi-use path to Old Town, which staff found sufficient for demand at that stage 06:18:12
- City staff said building hard transit improvements on the west side early would create throwaway work, since that area is developed in later phases 06:22:06
- City staff said conditions were written to allow for MTS's planned rapid Route 210, which may not arrive until 2035 06:23:15
- A councilmember said four councilmembers sit on the MTS board and he looks forward to continuing the conversation on getting transit improvements in place for the arena's opening 06:24:12
- A councilmember praised staff and the developer and called the project a vast improvement for the area 06:24:57
- The council president said the program matches what the council chose four years ago, recalling a pledge to withdraw support if there were a bait and switch 06:28:11
- The council president noted the parks are privately built and maintained but must be open to the public daily 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., and asked special-events staff to limit closures 06:31:10
- The council president disputed public claims that the site is in a flood plain 06:34:38
- The council president said it was a missed opportunity not to have the project contribute to upgrading the undersized storm water Pump Station H, though no amendment was offered 06:36:08
- City staff said, for the city's engineers, that all building floor elevations would sit above the most conservative state sea level rise projections 06:38:18
- City staff said the council approves the DDA and the forms of its attachments, except the affordable housing ground lease form, which was not finished and must come back 06:43:55
- City staff said the city's protections stay the same whether the build-out is fast or slow, and it gets revenue sooner if the developer moves faster 06:45:37
- City staff said groundbreaking can't happen until the horizontal ground lease closes and the DDA's performance triggers are met 06:46:45
- The council president predicted the project will spur redevelopment of the surrounding area, likening it to Horton Plaza and Petco Park 06:48:06
- The City Attorney's office said the affordable housing lease form is a condition of the horizontal ground lease, so the project can't proceed if the council rejects it 06:50:23
- The City Attorney's office said state law SB 344 sets affordability levels but no deadline for building the units 06:53:14
- A councilmember asked about section 15.3.6, which lets the developer delay some affordable units if gap financing can't be secured 06:59:52
- The Economic Development Department said that delay is allowed only in phases two or three 07:00:36
- The Economic Development Department explained that 1,063 units cited in a state letter is the Surplus Land Act minimum, but the developer is held to its 2,000-unit promise 07:04:54
- A Midway Rising representative said, for the affordable-housing developer, that it no longer uses subcontractors with compliance defaults and the project is subject to a project labor agreement 07:06:32
- A councilmember noted voting against selecting this developer in 2022 and said the city could have gotten a better financial deal 07:07:55
- A councilmember apologized to residents who questioned the project and said they had been mocked and belittled by leaders 07:08:57
- A councilmember criticized how the city negotiates land deals, arguing that signaling it would never walk away weakened its position 07:10:06
- A councilmember asked that the development team report back every year to a council committee on progress 07:16:18
Midway Rising tax-increment financing district Item 600
Bonds and debtDevelopment projects
Two resolutions: one declaring the city's intention to form the Midway Rising Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District (EIFD), and one creating its Public Financing Authority, the district's governing board (agenda). An EIFD cannot raise taxes. It redirects future growth in property tax inside the district, in this case 100% of the city's and county's shares for about 45 years, to repay the developer for public infrastructure it builds up front, such as streets, storm drains, utilities, parks and public portions of garages. That money would otherwise go to the city and county general funds. Staff projected about $1.2 billion in combined contributions, about 52% of it from the city; staff put the total at $148 million in today's dollars at a 6% discount rate; eligible costs were estimated at $370 million, or about $462 million with capital maintenance. The board would have seven members: two councilmembers, two county supervisors and three members of the public. Formation is not final until an infrastructure financing plan is approved by the city, the county and the authority, which staff expected in fiscal year 2028. 00:43:25
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved the staff recommendation on item 600, seconded by Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council); Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) was absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 07:19:08Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Vivian Moreno, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Marni von Wilpert. Moved by Jennifer Campbell, seconded by Kent Lee. From the clerk's record
- The Department of Finance explained that the district can't create or change taxes and instead captures future growth in property tax revenue 01:08:59
- The Department of Finance described a seven-member financing authority of two councilmembers, two county supervisors and three public members 01:09:59
- The Department of Finance said the district would be funded by 100% of the city's and county's shares of property tax growth 01:09:59
- The Department of Finance projected combined contributions of about $1.2 billion, about 52% from the city, and roughly $985 million available after bond debt service 01:13:07
- The Department of Finance put eligible costs at about $370 million initially and about $462 million including capital maintenance, excluding the developer's carrying costs 01:14:07
- The Department of Finance said it would take the district its full life to repay the developer, and projected revenues support at most a 3% annual carrying cost 01:15:08
- The Department of Finance said the resolution sets the first public hearing on the infrastructure financing plan for August 27, 2027 01:16:09
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office said about $370 million, roughly 80% of the project's infrastructure costs, could be reimbursed by the district 01:34:15
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office noted tax increment grows very slowly in the first fifteen years and likely won't pick up until after 2045 01:35:18
- A councilmember urged that staff quantify neighborhood infrastructure gaps, such as a new fire station, and make them eligible in the financing plan 06:10:40
- The council president asked whether the council will get to weigh in before the financing district is docketed for final approval 06:29:16
- City staff confirmed the council will have that opportunity 06:29:59
- The Department of Finance said storm water and flood-prevention work can generally be reimbursed if it has a tangible connection to the project 06:54:09
- The Department of Finance said that if the district can't repay infrastructure costs, the shortfall falls on the developer 06:55:09
Midway Rising land use approvals: plan amendment, rezone, specific plan and development agreement Item 601
Zoning and plansDevelopment projectsHistoric preservation
The land use package for the project (PRJ-1106734). It amends the General Plan and the Midway-Pacific Highway Community Plan, adopts the Midway Rising Specific Plan with signage exceptions, rezones 49.23 acres from CC-3-6 to the residential mixed-use RMX-2 zone, removes the site from the Community Plan Implementation Overlay Zone, adopts a development agreement, grants a variance to the inclusionary housing rules, creates a Midway Rising Entertainment Center District in the Municipal Code, and approves a vesting tentative map with easement vacations and a site development permit (agenda). The ordinances were introductions, and none of the subitems is subject to the Mayor's veto (agenda). Staff said allowed density rises from 44 to up to 72 homes per acre. The 30-year development agreement lists extraordinary benefits valued at $1.2 billion, including up to $2.5 million for Fire Station 20 upgrades. The site development permit is needed because the project demolishes the Sports Arena, a designated historic resource. The community planning group voted 7-0 and the Planning Commission 6-0 to recommend approval. The commission recommended putting the transit improvements in phase one; staff did not include that change. 00:43:25
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved the staff recommendation on item 601, seconded by Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council), with two amendments shown on screen: Joe LaCava (Councilmember, District 1; President, City Council)'s, removing the district identity pylon in the public right-of-way from the specific plan, Appendix B and Figure 44; and Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7)'s, adding a $2 million extraordinary-benefit payment to the development agreement for transportation improvements in the community planning area, due at the arena's final inspection or certificate of occupancy; Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) was absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 07:37:20Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Vivian Moreno, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Marni von Wilpert. Moved by Jennifer Campbell, seconded by Kent Lee. From the clerk's record
- City staff said, for Development Services, that the specific plan allows 4,254 homes, 2,000 of them affordable 01:18:11
- City staff said the community plan amendment raises allowed density to up to 72 homes per acre and repeals the overlay zone on the site 01:20:16
- City staff said the development agreement locks in development rules for thirty years in exchange for public benefits beyond standard requirements 01:25:29
- City staff said the benefits include an extra fee of up to $2.5 million for Fire Station 20 upgrades 01:26:30
- City staff said the site development permit is needed because the project demolishes the historic Sports Arena 01:26:30
- City staff said the area is not mapped in a FEMA special flood hazard area, though the shallow storm drain system has caused flooding 01:27:37
- City staff said the Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval with one recommendation, to put transit improvements in phase one 01:28:44
- City staff said staff did not include or recommend that change, citing too few homes in phase one and MTS's control over bus service 01:29:46
- The council president said the allowance for 250-foot buildings on 10% of the site surprised him and was not shown in the renderings 06:30:08
- The council president said he disliked the tower allowance but did not expect to have the votes to strike it 06:31:10
- The council president raised concerns about 50-foot sign pylons with moving images, citing distraction, bird impacts and the 30-foot height limit 06:38:37
- City staff said, for Development Services, that the pylon proposed in the public right-of-way is not allowed under current law 06:39:39
- A councilmember asked the developer to pay $2 million for traffic signal modernization to ease travel in and out of Point Loma, paid before the arena's building permit 06:57:24
- A Midway Rising representative agreed to an additional $2 million payment for traffic congestion relief in the Midway District 06:58:32
- The council president proposed removing the right-of-way pylon from the specific plan so it doesn't confuse future reviewers 07:19:08
- A councilmember asked whether a sign at the roundabout would create traffic problems 07:22:05
- A councilmember asked what traffic improvements the $2 million could cover, mentioning interest in transit signal priority 07:25:36
- A councilmember said the goal is to synchronize traffic signals so traffic flows 07:25:50
- City staff cautioned that whatever the money funds must be analyzed under state law, including environmental law 07:26:59
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office asked about the payment's timing, noting staff described it as due around the arena's final inspection 07:27:23
- A councilmember said writing the signal work into the amendment would be improper, so the Mayor's office was asked for an on-record commitment instead 07:35:48
- City staff confirmed the $2 million is an extraordinary-benefit payment under the development agreement, not tied to the DDA or its return hurdles 07:36:39
- City staff said the payment would be collected by City Planning 07:36:54
Public comment
- Closed session (6 speakers, 1 in person and 5 virtual): speakers tied the two trip-and-fall cases to the city's multibillion-dollar infrastructure backlog and urged sidewalk repairs. On the police shooting case, most questioned the police use of force and called for more training and accountability. One expressed sympathy for officers' split-second decisions, and one suggested asking settlement recipients to donate part of their awards.
- Midway Rising, organized presentations (11 submitted): the Midway Rising team asked for support, citing the $4.2 billion investment, 2,000 affordable homes, labor agreements, and childcare and health care partners. The chair of the Midway-Pacific Highway community planning group said the group voted unanimously in support, and an affordable-housing service provider described resident programs.
- Midway Rising, opposing organized presentations (about 7): a commercial real estate broker argued the rent, which the speaker put at $100,000 a year for 15 years on land the speaker said was appraised at $75 million, plus the financing district, make a bad deal. Others argued the lease chain exceeds the state's 99-year limit, the change in development partners required rebidding, and the affordability average was raised from below 50% to 60% of area median income. Others raised contamination from a former landfill, liquefaction, groundwater, sea level rise and flooding, and Rosecrans traffic. Most asked the council to deny or postpone (one suggested 90 days); a District 4 resident asked for an enforceable community benefits agreement and money for a permanent fire station.
- Midway Rising, individual speakers (the clerk counted 75 in the chambers when individual comment began, plus about two dozen virtual): most supported the project. Supporters included building trades, carpenters, laborers, stagehand (IATSE Local 122) and labor council representatives citing union jobs; seniors and families living in affordable housing; nonprofits; the regional chamber and EDC; and young pro-housing groups. Around 20 speakers, mostly from pro-housing groups, asked the council to move the transit improvements, especially bus lanes, into phase one. By Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7)'s count, 112 spoke in favor and 18 against.
- Midway Rising opponents among individual speakers raised flooding and sea level rise, unstable fill soil, traffic and emergency access in Point Loma and Old Town, the financing district as a subsidy to a billionaire developer, the possible shifting of affordable units from other projects, the height allowance and removal of the overlay zone, and waiting for the newly elected council. The swap meet operator on the site supported the project but asked the city for a plan to keep it operating or help it relocate.
- Written e-comments, as read by the clerk: item 600, 2 in favor and 44 opposed; item 601, 7 in favor and 20 opposed; item 602, 0 in favor and 8 opposed. The clerk also noted 13 speaker slips in favor from people who did not wish to speak.
- Non-agenda public comment (about 13 speakers): topics included flooding and the unintended consequences of rushed deals; thanks to a departing councilmember and to the council; a report on rents tracking median incomes, and tax increment financing for Mid-City; transit; license plate readers (one against Flock surveillance, one in favor of license plate recognition); thanks to a councilmember for raising transparency; ballot measure transparency; drug gangs and immigration enforcement; infrastructure lawsuits in low-income areas; and a complaint, with a video, about the clerk's media submission and unmuting procedures.
What's next
- The affordable housing ground lease form, the one DDA attachment not finished, must come back to the council; it is a condition of the horizontal ground lease. Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7) said there are 180 days from the meeting to finish negotiating it.
- Financing district: the resolution of intention goes to property owners and the county; seats on the financing authority are to be filled over about six months; the first public hearing on the infrastructure financing plan is set for August 27, 2027; the city, the county and the authority must each approve the plan, with formation expected in fiscal year 2028. Staff confirmed the council will weigh in before final docketing.
- The $2 million traffic payment under the development agreement is due at the arena's final inspection or certificate of occupancy (the record gives both terms). Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7) asked the mayor's team for an on-record commitment that it go to traffic signal work in the Point Loma area, and the transcript records a yes.
- Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7) asked that the development team report every year to a council committee; Joe LaCava (Councilmember, District 1; President, City Council) asked special-events staff to limit park closures under the district's annual event permit; Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council) asked staff to quantify infrastructure gaps, including a fire station, for the financing plan; Stephen Whitburn (Councilmember, District 3) said the transit timing discussion would continue, including at MTS.
- Joe LaCava (Councilmember, District 1; President, City Council) said storm water staff are still studying Pump Station H.
- The council adjourned to its regular meeting on Tuesday, November 10, 2026, at 10 a.m.
Write to the City Council before its next meeting: its comment form