· 5 items
City Council, Tuesday, October 27
On the episode: Council pauses data centers; flat water rate replaces tiers after court loss
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
City Council Tuesday, October 27
5 items
Ceremonial proclamations Item 30, S500, S501, S505
Four ceremonial proclamations, approved together: a day honoring the executive director of the Fair Housing Council of San Diego (Item 30, from Henry Foster (Councilmember, District 4) and Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9)); Mission Beach Women's Club Centennial Anniversary Day (S500, from Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2)); Handlery Hotel San Diego 70th Anniversary Day (S501, from Stephen Whitburn (Councilmember, District 3)); and Domestic Violence Awareness Month (S505, from Heather Ferbert (City Attorney), Marni von Wilpert (Councilmember, District 5) and Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7)). Members used them to highlight fair housing enforcement and the city's domestic violence services. 00:06:31
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved to approve the proclamation items (30, S500, S501, S505); Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9) seconded. Result: passed, 9-0. 00:36:01Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Marni von Wilpert, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Vivian Moreno, Sean Elo-Rivera. Moved by Jennifer Campbell, seconded by Sean Elo-Rivera. From the clerk's record
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved the proclamations and proclaimed November 7, 2026 as the Mission Beach Women's Club's centennial day, crediting the club with a century of support for schools, youth sports and nonprofits 00:16:36
- A councilmember credited the honoree with more than 33 years of fair housing advocacy, including a national fair housing law conference she hosts in San Diego 00:18:14
- A councilmember seconded and joined in recognizing October 27, 2026 as the honoree's day in the city 00:20:29
- A councilmember described the honoree's decades of fair housing enforcement as head of the Fair Housing Council of San Diego and her service on the city's Senior Affairs Advisory Board 00:21:31
- A councilmember thanked the City Attorney's Office for the Family Justice Center, and urged people not to pull away from someone who has experienced domestic violence 00:23:35
- A councilmember noted that the city funds interim housing for domestic violence survivors and their children 00:25:33
- A councilmember presented the proclamation for the hotel's 70th anniversary and noted four generations of one family have run it 00:25:33
- A councilmember said domestic violence is the leading cause of women's homelessness in San Diego and thanked Family Justice Center officers, detectives and case managers 00:29:16
- A councilmember said funding domestic violence programs is a fight in the budget every year 00:30:16
Emergency 45-day moratorium on new data centers Item S510
Data centersZoning and plans
An emergency ordinance, brought by the mayor's office after an executive order, that pauses citywide for 45 days the acceptance, processing and approval of permits for new, expanded or intensified data centers, plus a resolution finding it exempt from CEQA. Staff said the city's code doesn't define data centers and currently permits them under rules for telecom switching stations. They cited the facilities' demands on electricity, water and land and the risk of higher utility bills. The pause has exemptions, including small accessory server rooms, public safety and emergency communications facilities, telecom carrier and utility facilities, and minor repairs that don't add floor area, power or water demand. It doesn't apply to federal land, including the Navy's NAVWAR campus near Old Town, where news reports described a proposed 400-megawatt data center. The agenda says the ordinance needed 8 votes under state law and isn't subject to the mayor's veto. The item was moved from Monday so at least eight members would be present. 00:42:48
- Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9) moved the staff recommendation (CEQA exemption resolution, plus introduction and adoption of the emergency ordinance) with added direction that isn't written into the ordinance: staff notify the council within seven days of any data center developer inquiry; a set of principles for the permanent policy; progress updates from the working group, the first within 45 days; and lobbying by the Office of Government Affairs against a large data center at NAVWAR. Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council) seconded. Result: passed, 9-0. 02:47:59Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Marni von Wilpert, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Vivian Moreno, Sean Elo-Rivera. Moved by Sean Elo-Rivera, seconded by Kent Lee. From the clerk's record
- The mayor's office said the municipal code doesn't define data centers, which are permitted today under rules written for telecom switching stations 00:44:35
- The mayor's office explained the ordinance would set a 45-day moratorium within the city's jurisdiction while rules are written 00:44:35
- The mayor's office acknowledged the moratorium does not settle what happens on the federally owned Navy site and said the city's government affairs team would press Sacramento and Washington 00:45:36
- City staff explained the ordinance takes effect immediately with a four-fifths vote and lasts 45 days, with a possible extension after another noticed hearing 00:47:41
- City staff noted the city has no land use authority over the federal NAVWAR site but said the proposal there shows how immediate the interest in large data centers is 00:50:53
- City staff listed exemptions, starting with accessory server rooms that serve only on-site operations 00:54:04
- City staff said the mayor signed an executive order last Thursday creating a stakeholder working group, whose input will shape Land Development Code amendments returning to council next year 00:55:05
- A councilmember allowed public comment on both the moratorium and the proposal on federal land, calling the federal proposal a separate matter 00:56:55
- A councilmember reminded members the emergency action needs eight yes votes, which is why it was moved from Monday 02:20:08
- City staff explained state law allows 45 days at first, then an extension of up to 10 months and 15 days, then another of up to a year 02:21:22
- A councilmember cited a Voice of San Diego report that a developer was exploring a 400-megawatt data center at the Navy site and called on the congressional delegation to stop it 02:23:49
- A councilmember asked staff about the ordinance's statement that industry representatives were interested in standalone data centers and vacant office space 02:23:49
- City staff answered that staff was mainly citing newspaper reports on the Navy site and possible downtown sites in empty buildings 02:24:27
- The mayor's office said the working group is still being formed and would include labor, community advocates, utility, water, housing, technology, environmental and higher education representatives 02:26:47
- A councilmember objected to including SDG&E in the working group and suggested San Diego Community Power instead 02:27:19
- A councilmember moved the item with added direction, including that staff notify the council within seven days of any inquiry from a prospective data center developer 02:28:34
- A councilmember proposed principles for the permanent policy: no by-right approval, approval only if housing isn't feasible on the site, all-renewable power, no fossil fuel backup, and recycled water for cooling 02:28:34
- A councilmember also asked for working group progress updates, the first within 45 days, and for the Office of Government Affairs to lobby against a large data center at NAVWAR 02:29:35
- A councilmember asked the city attorneys to confirm the added direction wouldn't compromise the moratorium's legal requirements 02:30:26
- A councilmember said he requested legal research on regulating data centers in early August and had been preparing a policy for his committee 02:31:20
- A councilmember described the Navy site proposal as a hyperscale campus of 400 to 500 megawatts, far larger than typical data centers 02:32:22
- A councilmember argued families and small businesses should not pay for data centers' water, power and infrastructure, and cited a recent papal encyclical on concentrated technological power 02:34:36
- A councilmember warned some members might need to leave by 1 p.m. and the item needed eight yes votes 02:36:21
- A councilmember said he was confident the council would extend the moratorium for the following ten and a half months 02:38:09
- A councilmember argued the Navy site, next to the Old Town Amtrak station and transit center, should be used for housing, including for service members 02:38:09
- A councilmember called the Navy site a once-in-a-generation opportunity for housing and transit-oriented development 02:40:16
- A councilmember asked whether the city, not an applicant, decides if a project qualifies for an exemption, and staff confirmed it does 02:41:18
- A councilmember said data centers must cover their own electricity and water costs and create good jobs for local skilled workers, and that she would vote yes 02:42:04
- A councilmember said he supports making things harder for data centers, as speakers urged, but that it will take time to make the required findings 02:44:31
- A councilmember called for studying the leverage the city has through its utility franchise agreement and its role in community power 02:45:32
- A councilmember warned the NAVWAR developer that if the data center proposal is a stalking horse for another agenda, there would be a price to pay 02:45:32
- An attorney for the city clarified for the record that the amendments are part of the motion but won't be written into the ordinance 02:47:08
- City staff said staff had no concerns with the added direction but would look into some items and report back 02:47:29
Water rates switch from tiered to single flat rate after court ruling Item 330
WaterLawsuits and settlements
The city has to replace its tiered single-family water rates with one unitary rate per unit of water for all customer classes. A lawsuit by high-volume single-family users ended with courts ruling the tiers didn't meet Proposition 218's proof requirements, and the state Supreme Court declined review. Staff said total water revenue doesn't change, and the already-adopted 14.5% increase for January 1, 2027 stays in place. What changes is who pays: staff estimated a low-volume single-family customer pays about $5.62 more a month (7.1%) and a high-volume single-family customer about $19.52 less. The city is also paying a $40 million settlement council had already approved. The public hearing closed October 6, when protests fell far short of a majority. 03:41:59
▶ Hear it What if the city refused the court-ordered water rates? · 0:52
- Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9) moved the staff recommendation to approve the unitary water rate adjustments, with an added request that the Public Utilities Department work with the IBA to update and expand water customer assistance programs, identify resources including eligible non-rate revenue, and return to the Environment Committee with a framework and funding plan. Joe LaCava (Councilmember, District 1; President, City Council) seconded. Result: passed, 6-2. No: Henry Foster (Councilmember, District 4), Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council). 04:36:03Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Raul Campillo, Vivian Moreno, Sean Elo-Rivera. Noes: Henry Foster, Kent Lee. Absent: Marni von Wilpert. Moved by Sean Elo-Rivera, seconded by Joe LaCava. From the clerk's record
- The city clerk reported 3,644 protests in the protest period, against the 132,968 needed for a majority protest 03:41:59
- City staff said the city disagrees with the court decision but is legally required to adopt a rate structure the court deems valid 03:43:48
- City staff pointed customers who can't afford the change to zero-interest payment options 03:44:48
- City staff explained that the plaintiffs, high-volume single-family users, argued they were subsidizing lower tiers 03:45:53
- City staff said the courts didn't reject industry-standard cost allocation, only found it didn't meet Prop 218's burden of proof 03:45:53
- City staff said the city must pay a $40 million settlement and the planned 14.5% increase for January 1, 2027 is unchanged 03:48:02
- City staff said no more capital projects need to be delayed to cover the settlement, and total revenue collected stays the same 03:48:02
- City staff estimated a low-volume single-family user's bill rises about $5.62 a month 03:50:07
- City staff estimated a high-volume single-family user's bill falls about $19.52 a month 03:51:09
- City staff said the required notice went to about 286,000 customers, and 27 legal objections are in the docket with responses 03:51:09
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office said the existing tiers rested on standard industry methods but strongly cautioned against rejecting the proposal, warning that more litigation costs would ultimately fall on ratepayers 03:54:15
- A councilmember said the ruling penalizes customers who conserved and rewards those who didn't 04:09:53
- City staff described efforts to raise non-rate revenue from leasing department property, solar and grants, and said staff would return in February with the cost of service study 04:12:04
- City staff said tiered rates could come back under a new state law, AB 2180, but not before rate increases after 2030, while a pending case tests how the law applies 04:14:34
- City staff said the state Supreme Court asked for briefing on how AB 2180 applies in a case against the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power 04:15:36
- A councilmember blamed anti-government activists and the wealthy for state rules that limit fair fee structures 04:16:41
- A councilmember moved the staff recommendation, adding a request that the utilities department and the IBA expand water customer assistance programs and return to the Environment Committee with a funding plan 04:18:58
- A councilmember seconded, noting other water agencies statewide use the same method the city was faulted for 04:19:46
- A councilmember asked about state efforts to create low-income relief for water like the one that exists for electricity 04:20:47
- City staff said staff supports legislative efforts for a statewide water subsidy program 04:21:29
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) explained the case's history for the public, saying it began in 2015, and said the city must comply or face fines 04:22:34
- City staff said not complying would bring back the full $120 million judgment the city settled for $40 million, plus interest and penalties 04:27:54
- City staff estimated that the extra liability would equal layoffs of at least about 800 staff 04:28:29
- City staff said the next court hearing is around December 11 and the city agreed with the court to set rates effective January 1 04:30:37
- City staff said the water system's outstanding debt of $1 billion to $2 billion could be called if bond covenants are violated 04:31:37
- A councilmember noted a dissenting appellate judge found the city's work sufficient and the majority did not rule tiered rates improper in themselves 04:32:44
- A councilmember said he voted against the 2025 rate increase and would oppose this too, since it shifts costs to low users and smaller households 04:33:44
- A councilmember urged assistance for low-income households and seniors, noting the city just did so for trash fees 04:34:53
- A councilmember asked the mayor's office to confirm that a public commenter who had left was offered help 04:36:12
- The mayor's office said he walked the commenter out and offered to be a resource 04:36:45
$5 million loan for The Joule affordable housing in Grantville Item S506
Affordable housing
A $5 million city loan (agenda) from the Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Fund, under the Bridge to Home program, to Mission Gorge Optima LP. The developer is a partnership owned by Wakeland Housing and Development Corporation. The money goes to The Joule, a planned eight-story building at 6255 Mission Gorge Road in Grantville, District 7, with 208 affordable studio, two- and three-bedroom apartments for families earning 30% to 60% of area median income. Staff gave the loan terms as 3% simple interest over 55 years, repaid from residual receipts, with 55-year affordability covenants. The total project is estimated at about $169 million, and construction could start as early as the end of 2028. It was presented jointly with S507 but voted on separately. 04:37:18
▶ Hear it What a new affordable apartment costs to build · 0:28
- Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7) moved the staff recommendation on S506; Stephen Whitburn (Councilmember, District 3) seconded. Result: passed, 8-0. 05:07:39Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Vivian Moreno, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Marni von Wilpert. Moved by Raul Campillo, seconded by Stephen Whitburn. From the clerk's record
- City staff asked council to authorize a $5 million loan from the Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Fund for each of the two projects 04:38:23
- City staff said 30 Bridge to Home loans in all will create nearly 3,000 affordable homes, with eight funding rounds since 2021 04:39:30
- City staff described the eight-story project with 208 affordable apartments for families in Grantville 04:41:40
- City staff said the city loan works out to about $24,000 per apartment and $13,000 per bedroom, and the total cost to about $169 million 04:42:43
- City staff gave the loan terms: 3% simple interest, a 55-year term repaid from residual receipts, and 55-year affordability covenants 04:43:48
- City staff said construction could start as early as the end of 2028 and take about 26 months once financing is secured 04:44:56
- A councilmember noted 53 of the 208 homes are for extremely low-income households and that the county owns the site and chose the developer 04:56:56
- A councilmember stressed the site is in a high-resource census tract, saying the city has legal and moral obligations to add affordable housing in such neighborhoods 04:56:56
- A councilmember asked staff for cost per unit and per bedroom, which he said the council had come to expect 05:00:30
- City staff calculated total project cost at about $803,000 per unit and $444,000 per bedroom 05:05:07
- A councilmember said costs should be pushed as low as possible but per-bedroom cost better reflects how many people are housed 05:05:20
$5 million loan for Salvation Army Rady Center Phase II senior housing downtown Item S507
Affordable housingSeniors and disability
A $5 million city loan (agenda) from the Low and Moderate Income Housing Asset Fund, under the Bridge to Home program, to TSA Perm Housing LP for Phase II of the Salvation Army Rady Center at 825 7th Avenue in East Village, District 3. Wakeland Housing and Development Corporation is building it on a 99-year ground lease from the Salvation Army. Staff described a six-story building with 89 affordable studio and one-bedroom apartments for seniors earning 30% to 60% of area median income. Total cost is about $64 million, and construction could start as early as the end of 2027. The loan terms are the same as S506. 04:37:18
- Stephen Whitburn (Councilmember, District 3) moved the staff recommendation on S507; Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7) seconded. Result: passed, 8-0. 05:08:33Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Vivian Moreno, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Marni von Wilpert. Moved by Stephen Whitburn, seconded by Raul Campillo. From the clerk's record
- City staff said the site is owned by the Salvation Army and will be built under a 99-year ground lease 04:40:33
- City staff described a six-story building with 89 affordable studios and one-bedrooms for senior households 04:43:48
- City staff said the loan is about $56,000 per apartment and per bedroom, with a total project cost of about $64 million 04:43:48
- City staff said construction could begin as early as the end of 2027 04:44:56
- A councilmember backed the project in his district, saying too many seniors are being priced out and falling into homelessness 04:59:42
- A councilmember asked why the downtown building is only six stories, and a developer representative said the roughly 90-unit count reflected the Salvation Army's vision and available financing 05:05:48
Public comment
- Proclamations (Items 30, S500, S501, S505): about seven speakers, one in person and the rest remote. Several praised the fair housing honoree, including a longtime colleague calling from out of state and a relative. Others spoke on Domestic Violence Awareness Month, and one urged attention to alcohol and drugs as factors in domestic violence.
- Data center moratorium (S510): the clerk said 45 speakers were signed up at the start. Roughly 70 spoke in total, nearly 30 in person and about 40 remote. Nearly all supported the moratorium, and many said 45 days was too short and asked for a year or longer, or a permanent ban. Common reasons were high SDG&E electricity bills, water use in a drought-prone region, noise, air pollution from backup generators, loss of land that could be used for housing, and wildlife. Many opposed the data center reported for the Navy's NAVWAR/Old Town site and urged federal action. Several urged a no vote on Proposition 45. Speakers included about five from the Sierra Club, two from San Diego 350, and representatives of the Environmental Health Coalition, the Coastal Environmental Rights Foundation, the Center on Policy Initiatives and a worker group. Two in-person speakers performed satirical characters mocking the pro-data-center side. Two callers urged the city to make utility hookups for data centers prohibitively expensive. The clerk reported 6 more in-person slips in favor without speaking and 157 written eComments in favor and 41 opposed, then clarified that all 41 opposed comments were against data centers.
- Non-agenda public comment (morning session, extended past noon): about 25 speakers. Four asked the city to repair the deteriorated, non-ADA-compliant parking lot at the Mira Mesa Senior Center; one said a 900-signature petition was being submitted to Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council) and suggested two Mira Mesa funds to pay for it. About five raised youth substance use, marijuana and vaping, asking for limits on cannabis advertising and businesses and for a smoke-free public places ordinance; one speaker objected that these issues shouldn't take priority over housing and the sewage crisis. One alleged serious misconduct by staff at a city-contracted safe lot operator and asked for an independent investigation. Others asked to keep the Mission Bay restrooms open permanently, complained about La Jolla Cove, urged dropping Flock license plate readers, told members to look attentive to speakers, and alleged remote callers were being prevented from unmuting. Several thanked members.
- Water rates (Item 330): about 11 speakers. Most opposed or criticized the increase, citing affordability and conservation efforts. One in-person speaker said her bill had risen sharply despite heavy conservation, and later interrupted the hearing. One caller criticized outreach for relying on the Union-Tribune rather than community newspapers. One questioned the role of personnel and contract costs. San Diego Coastkeeper asked the council to start a new cost-of-service study to restore conservation tiers and to treat the flat rate as temporary. One speaker supported the staff recommendation as legally necessary.
- Affordable housing loans (S506, S507): six speakers. Two in person and two remote supported the projects, including the Downtown San Diego Partnership for S507. One opposed both for reasons unrelated to the projects. One caller questioned S507's per-unit cost and whether the city would ever recover the loan.
What's next
- Data center moratorium: it lasts 45 days from passage. Staff said it can be extended up to 10 months and 15 days after another noticed public hearing, then up to one more year. Kent Lee (Councilmember, District 6; President Pro Tem, City Council) predicted the council would approve the longer extension.
- Sean Elo-Rivera (Councilmember, District 9)'s motion asks the mayor's data center working group to report progress back to council, the first update within 45 days. The City Planning Department is to bring Land Development Code amendments regulating data centers to council next year.
- Staff is to notify the council within seven days of any inquiry from a prospective data center developer, and the Office of Government Affairs is to lobby against a large data center at NAVWAR (direction in the motion, not in the ordinance).
- Water: the new unitary rates and the previously adopted 14.5% increase take effect January 1, 2027. Staff said the next court hearing in the case is around December 11.
- Public Utilities plans to return in February with its cost of service study and an update on customer relief options. Separately, it is to work with the IBA and bring a framework and funding plan for expanded water customer assistance to the Environment Committee.
- Staff said reintroducing tiered water rates would be considered only for increases taking effect after 2030, after a pending state Supreme Court case on AB 2180.
- Bridge to Home: three remaining Round 7 loan agreements come to council early next year, and Round 8 applications are under review.
- Next council meeting: Monday, November 9, 2026, at 10 a.m. There are no council meetings on Monday, November 2, or Tuesday, November 3.
- Public notice (agenda): the City Engineer approves the 'Harvey Milk' final map at 1661 Harvey Milk St. Appeals are due to the City Clerk within 10 calendar days of this meeting.
Write to the City Council before its next meeting: its comment form