· 5 items
City Council, Monday, October 26
On the episode: Council pauses data centers; flat water rate replaces tiers after court loss
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
City Council Monday, October 26
5 items
Overhaul of the city's arts and culture funding policy Item 613
Arts and cultureCivil rights and equity
Revisions to Council Policy 100-03 (titled "Transient Occupancy Tax" on the agenda) that update the framework for the city's arts and culture grant programs, the Organizational Support Program and Creative Communities San Diego, and align the arts and culture funding area with others overseen by the Economic Development Department. According to the IBA's Division of Race and Equity, the new model would score applications 60% on demonstrated impact and 40% on annual operating income, instead of basing allocations almost entirely on operating income; would move payments from 85% upfront and 15% after year-end reports to a single upfront payment; and would create three subcategories separating smaller and emerging organizations from larger ones. Councilmembers also cited multi-year agreements and a simpler application. Who gets city arts grants, and how much, depends on this formula. It passed as part of the consent agenda. 00:12:35
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved, and Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7) seconded, to adopt the consent agenda (Items 600 through 614), including Item 613. Result: passed, 8-0. 00:47:55Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Marni von Wilpert, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Vivian Moreno. Moved by Jennifer Campbell, seconded by Raul Campillo. From the clerk's record
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office said, for its Division of Race and Equity, that an explicit amendment would be offered requiring recipients to incur and pay eligible expenses and provide proof, with payment schedules set in program guidelines and written agreements 00:13:04
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office noted that the new model moves grant payments from a split of 85% upfront and 15% after year-end reports to a single upfront payment 00:14:05
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office said the payment terms particularly affect historically underserved organizations and those serving low- to moderate-income communities, which often have smaller budgets and may lack cash to front costs and wait for reimbursement 00:14:05
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office explained that scoring would shift to 60% on an organization's demonstrated impact and 40% on its annual operating income, calling it a more equitable approach for smaller organizations 00:15:05
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office suggested that after this grant cycle the council could ask Cultural Affairs whether the 60/40 split should tilt further toward impact, and ask how panelists will score impact 00:15:05
- The Independent Budget Analyst's office recommended the council keep watching arts funding in next spring's proposed budget, since that amount determines whether every applicant can be funded and at what level 00:16:06
- A councilmember argued arts nonprofits should spend more time serving communities and less navigating city bureaucracy, calling the changes a good way forward 00:35:49
- A councilmember voiced strong support for multi-year agreements, upfront payments and a simpler application process 00:37:02
- A councilmember asked the mayor's office for a staff presentation on the changes at the ED and IR committee soon, noting it hadn't been able to go there first 00:37:02
- The mayor's office said it would bring an information update to the committee in the coming weeks 00:37:02
- A councilmember said moving to 100% upfront payments, as the council has already done with its own CPPS and ACCF funding, makes a large difference for smaller organizations 00:39:22
- A councilmember cautioned that the new system only works if the budget actually funds arts and culture, and said stability matters for small organizations 00:40:23
- A councilmember asked the mayor's office and the economic development director to respond to the Division of Race and Equity's analysis 00:42:00
- The Economic Development Department said the equity division went through the calculations with the department, and that the department wants to learn from how the new formula performs 00:42:44
- A councilmember said past funding cycles tended to favor established organizations expecting a trickle-down effect that does not work, and said he would be watching for true impact 00:43:30
- A councilmember cited the Design Capital 2024 effort as falling short on commitments to include smaller, grassroots organizations, especially in District 4 00:44:32
- A councilmember said he docketed the item because of application timelines, after verifying that extensive outreach had been done 00:46:26
- A councilmember said someone close to the issue told him smaller organizations would likely benefit and some bigger organizations would likely see less funding 00:46:26
- A councilmember noted that as a council policy it can be easily adjusted if results are not what the council hoped 00:47:29
Ban on smoking and vaping in outdoor dining areas introduced Item 601
Public health
First reading (introduction) of an ordinance amending the Municipal Code to prohibit smoking and vaping in outdoor dining areas citywide. Its sponsor said it sets one consistent citywide standard to protect diners from secondhand smoke and give restaurants clarity. It was introduced as part of the consent agenda, not yet adopted. 00:34:40
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved, and Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7) seconded, to adopt the consent agenda, which introduced the Item 601 ordinance. Result: passed, 8-0. 00:47:55Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Marni von Wilpert, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Vivian Moreno. Moved by Jennifer Campbell, seconded by Raul Campillo. From the clerk's record
- A councilmember said the ordinance sets a consistent citywide standard prohibiting smoking and vaping in outdoor dining areas, protecting health and giving restaurants and patrons clarity 00:34:40
- A councilmember credited research from San Diego State University's Center for Tobacco and Environment and input from the California Restaurant Association 00:34:40
- A councilmember supported the item as a step to let families and workers dine outdoors without secondhand smoke and vaping 00:38:15
Appointment to the Community Forest Advisory Board Item 609
Appointments and leadershipParks and trees
Confirms a mayoral appointment to the Community Forest Advisory Board for a term ending December 31, 2027 (agenda). The agenda lists the affected areas as District 7 and outside city limits, and a councilmember noted the appointee doesn't live in the city. 00:35:49
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved, and Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7) seconded, to adopt the consent agenda, including Item 609. Result: passed, 8-0. 00:47:55Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Marni von Wilpert, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Vivian Moreno. Moved by Jennifer Campbell, seconded by Raul Campillo. From the clerk's record
- A councilmember thanked the appointee for volunteering and said he brings unique qualifications even though he is not a city resident 00:35:49
Wage theft and sick leave ordinance amendments adopted Item 604
Jobs and wages
Adoption (second reading) of amendments to the city's Earned Sick Leave and Minimum Wage Ordinance meant to strengthen the city's ability to combat wage theft and to align the city's sick leave rules with state law. It was introduced 8-0 on October 13, 2026 (agenda) and adopted as part of the consent agenda. 00:38:15
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved, and Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7) seconded, to adopt the consent agenda, including Item 604. Result: passed, 8-0. 00:47:55Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Marni von Wilpert, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Vivian Moreno. Moved by Jennifer Campbell, seconded by Raul Campillo. From the clerk's record
- A councilmember thanked colleagues for supporting the amendments and called wage theft unacceptable, saying the changes help workers get the wages they earned 00:38:15
City property at 4069 30th Street declared surplus land Item 612
Affordable housing
Declares city-owned property at 4069 30th Street (District 3) surplus land under the state Surplus Land Act, the step that comes before a notice of availability offering the site to others. The presiding officer asked that the offering favor a lease rather than a sale, which he tied to affordable housing. 00:45:24
- Jennifer Campbell (Councilmember, District 2) moved, and Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7) seconded, to adopt the consent agenda, including Item 612. Result: passed, 8-0. 00:47:55Ayes: Joe LaCava, Jennifer Campbell, Stephen Whitburn, Henry Foster, Marni von Wilpert, Kent Lee, Raul Campillo, Sean Elo-Rivera. Absent: Vivian Moreno. Moved by Jennifer Campbell, seconded by Raul Campillo. From the clerk's record
- A councilmember thanked Economic Development and the Land Use and Housing Committee, which separated this property from others on a list, and asked that the notice of availability focus on leasing rather than sale 00:45:24
- A councilmember argued leasing can produce more truly affordable housing than a market-rate sale, and recalled that changes to Council Policy 700-10 made leasing the default 00:45:24
Public comment
- Five members of the public commented on the consent agenda, one in person and four remotely, most of them on several items.
- Tijuana sewage emergency (Item 610): five speakers. One urged tariffs or cutting off water deliveries to Mexico until the pollution is fixed; one argued the city helped create the emergency by backing infrastructure decades ago and that it is now an ongoing condition rather than an emergency; one urged dialogue and cooperation with Mexican partners; one blamed state and Democratic leadership and money spent on studies; one questioned whether the repeatedly extended emergency has simply become how government works.
- Legal settlements (Items 607, 608): four speakers spoke on them. One said the La Jolla Terrace settlement was nearly $4 million and a sidewalk settlement about $250,000 (figures not in the agenda); one warned that with rising seas and stronger storms, damage like La Jolla Terrace's will cost taxpayers more unless the city inspects its underground infrastructure more thoroughly; one proposed tracking what plaintiffs do with settlement money; the in-person speaker asked when the city will fix sidewalks so such settlements stop.
- Arts and culture consolidation and funding policy (Items 603, 613): two speakers were unsure or concerned whether all organizations could be funded equitably and whether the merged department has enough resources; one praised the Division of Race and Equity's analysis. A different speaker called the racial equity work itself racist.
- Wage theft amendments (Item 604): two speakers supported them; one asked how the city would enforce them when undocumented workers fear employer retaliation.
- Petroleum pipeline franchise (Item 605): one speaker questioned how a 25-year petroleum pipeline franchise fits the city's climate action plan and why it is exempt from CEQA.
- Outdoor dining smoking ban (Item 601): two speakers; one suggested recycling cigarette butts, and one supported the ban but asked what happens to hookah bars.
- Other items: one speaker asked whether the $7 million footwear contract (Item 602) was too high; one supported the wastewater vacuum-pumping contract (Item 611), and another used it to urge the city to examine groundwater and sea-level pressure on sewer pipes; one supported declaring the 30th Street property surplus (Item 612).
- During councilmember comments, a person in chambers interrupted; the presiding officer said someone would come talk with him and continued the meeting.
What's next
- The mayor's office said it would bring an information update on the Item 613 arts funding changes to the council's ED and IR committee in the coming weeks, at Raul Campillo (Councilmember, District 7)'s request.
- Item S401, originally set for Monday afternoon, was moved to Tuesday, October 27, 10 a.m. session as Item S510. The presiding officer said it requires eight votes and was moved so the full council could consider it.
- Consent items normally heard Tuesday morning were handled at this special Monday meeting, and consent will not be taken up Tuesday. Afterward the special meeting was adjourned; the presiding officer said the council would then convene its regular Monday meeting, starting with public comment on closed session items. The recording ends before the regular meeting convenes.
- The Item 601 smoking and vaping ordinance and the Item 605 pipeline franchise ordinance were only introduced and have not been adopted; the franchise ordinance requires 6 votes (agenda).
- For the 4069 30th Street property (Item 612), a notice of availability is to come next; the presiding officer asked that it favor a lease over a sale.
- The IBA's Division of Race and Equity recommended watching arts and culture funding in the proposed budget due next spring, and suggested revisiting the 60/40 scoring split after this grant cycle.
- A councilmember said he looks forward to presenting in the future on finding more sustainable arts and culture funding.
Write to the City Council before its next meeting: its comment form